Switch to ADA Accessible Theme
Close Menu
New Name, Same Team learn More
Schedule a Confidential Consultation Today! 352-567-0411 Dade City

Police Officer Seen Planting Evidence In DUI Arrest


Police officers are supposed to protect the community from criminals, but sometimes they do things to arrest innocent people, such as planting evidence. This happened during a routine traffic stop in Tallahassee last May.

The police officer, a 26-year-old woman, pulled over a 56-year-old man for driving with a suspended license. She detained the man and called for backup. When another officer walked over to the man to question him, bodycam footage showed the female officer handling a bottle of cognac. She poured the alcohol into the man’s car during the search and accused the man of opening it inside the vehicle.

Despite claims of smelling alcohol, there was no immediate evidence of impairment. There was a discussion among the police officers caught on bodycam. It showed a strategy to arrest the man for DUI, even though they did not have concrete evidence.

The female officer needed to move the man from her police car to another officer’s vehicle, so she called in a senior officer for more backup. She suggested parking the man’s car in a nearby church so he wouldn’t have to pay any fees for getting his car back. Between posting his $750 bond and legal fees, and missing work at the barbershop, he missed several car payments before forfeiting his car.

The man has filed a lawsuit. His legal representation is focusing on the lack of a policy that prohibits the impounding of liquids as evidence. The Tallahassee Police Department issued a statement claiming that they did not find any evidence of misconduct. The man’s case has now gone to trial.

Why Do Police Officers Plant Evidence?

Police officers planting evidence is a serious breach of ethics. It undermines the trust between law enforcement and the public. There are several potential reasons why a police officer might engage in such unethical behavior, such as the following:

  • Pressure to solve cases. In some cases, there may be pressure from superiors or the community to solve a case quickly, especially in high-profile or politically sensitive situations. This pressure could lead some officers to resort to planting evidence to secure a conviction.
  • Confirmation bias. Sometimes, police officers might become convinced of a suspect’s guilt based on incomplete or circumstantial evidence. This confirmation bias can lead them to believe that planting evidence is justified in order to secure what they perceive as a fair outcome.
  • Personal bias or prejudice. Prejudice or personal bias against certain individuals or groups might lead some officers to frame suspects by planting evidence.
  • Lack of oversight or accountability. In environments where there is insufficient oversight or accountability, some officers may engage in unethical behavior, including planting evidence, because they believe they won’t be caught or punished.

Seek Help for Your DUI Case

DUI charges can often be challenged, especially when something like this happens. Planting evidence is not something that should be tolerated by a police officer.

DUI charges often get reduced or dismissed after all the facts become known. The Dade City & Zephyrhills DUI defense attorneys from Madonna Law Group have the experience, knowledge, and determination to get our clients the best possible outcome. To schedule a consultation with our office, call (800) 557-0411 or fill out the online form.


© 2016 - 2024 Madonna Law Group. All rights reserved.
This law firm website and legal marketing is managed by MileMark Media.